Old Bay Insurance Agency has been serving the Annapolis, Greater Anne Arundel County, and Queen Anne's County areas for over 25 years. Our company has had the privilege of working with thousands of families, individuals, and young adults for various insurance needs. From our earliest beginnings to the present day, we have been dedicated to providing exceptional service and ensuring that our clients' needs are met.
Our History
The origin of our agency's name dates back to when our owner, Neal Tatterson, was brainstorming with family and friends around the dinner table. It was decided that everything is indeed better with Old Bay. And so, the name stuck. Our approach to insurance is built on building strong relationships. Who better to work with than someone who has an intimate understanding of the insurance industry?
Our Commitment
At Old Bay Insurance Agency, we understand that insurance may not be at the top of your "favorite things to do" list. That's why we strive to make the process as seamless and efficient as possible. Our experienced agents take the time to get to know our clients' current coverage situations and identify areas where we can improve their coverage. Our motto is that we serve our clients' needs, not the needs of a large insurance company. As an independent broker, we have the ability to choose from various insurance companies, ensuring that we find the best policy for our clients at a price that fits their budget.
Our Services
At Old Bay Insurance Agency, we offer a comprehensive range of insurance services, including:
- Personal Insurance
+ Auto Insurance
+ Home Insurance
+ Life Insurance
+ Renters Insurance
+ Property Insurance
- Commercial Insurance
+ Business Liability Insurance
+ Commercial Property Insurance
+ Contractors Insurance
+ Cyber Liability Insurance
+ E & O Insurance
- Specialty Insurance
+ Boating Insurance
+ Classic Car Insurance
+ Motorcycle Insurance
+ RV Insurance
+ Umbrella Insurance
Our Team
Our team of experienced agents, including Neal Tatterson, Jeanie Fletcher, Rick Bowers, Sharon Richards, and Vickie Holder, are dedicated to providing exceptional service and ensuring that our clients' needs are met. With over 60 years of combined insurance experience, our team has the expertise to navigate even the most complex insurance situations.
Client Testimonials
We are proud to have worked with numerous satisfied clients, including Carolyn Riggins, Jo Burkholder, David Vogel, Roger Gerst, Christian Dimenna, and Jason Guest, who have all praised our personalized service and commitment to providing the best possible insurance solutions.
Customer Service and Support
The customers praised the exceptional customer service and support provided by Old Bay Insurance. Neal, Sharon, and other staff members were commended for their prompt responses, kindness, professionalism, and willingness to help with any questions or concerns.
Professionalism and Expertise
The reviewers appreciated the expertise and knowledge of the Old Bay Insurance team, particularly Neal and Sharon. They were able to find the best insurance plans, saved customers money, and provided reassurance throughout the process.
Personalized Service
Many customers highlighted the personalized service they received from Old Bay Insurance. Neal and his team took the time to understand their specific needs and requirements, providing tailored solutions that met their unique situations.
Efficiency and Responsiveness
The customers praised the promptness and efficiency of Old Bay Insurance. They responded quickly to queries, and in some cases, went above and beyond to provide necessary documents or assistance.
Recommendations
The reviewers highly recommended Old Bay Insurance, praising the agency's ability to provide excellent customer service, competitive rates, and personalized attention.
