Mitchell Insurance Agency

At Mitchell Insurance Agency of Oshkosh, we care about providing personalized insurance solutions tailored to meet your unique needs. Our agency is family-owned and operated, with over 30 years of experience in the insurance industry. We are dedicated to offering the best service, locally, with a focus on building long-term relationships with our customers.

Our Story

Our agency was founded by Jim Mitchell, who has been in the insurance business for over 38 years. Jim's goal was to establish an independent agency that could offer a wide range of insurance options to the community, with a commitment to providing exceptional customer service. Over the years, we have built a reputation for excellence, earning recognition as the Best Insurance Agency in Winnebago County for ten years running, and Jim has been voted Best Insurance Agent in Winnebago County and Milwaukee Journal Sentinel in 2022 and 2023.

Our Services

We offer a comprehensive range of insurance services, including auto, home, business, commercial, renters, recreational, SR-22's, life, and senior products. Our team is dedicated to taking the hassle out of buying and managing insurance, ensuring that you receive the best coverage at a competitive price.

Meet Our Team

Jim Mitchell, our owner and president, is a top-producing agent with extensive experience in the insurance industry. He is supported by a dedicated team who share his commitment to exceptional customer service. Our team is available to meet with you in person, or we can conduct meetings virtually to accommodate your preferences.

Community Involvement

At Mitchell Insurance Agency, we are deeply involved in our community. Jim has held leadership positions in local and non-profit organizations and has been an active volunteer. We believe in giving back to the community that has supported us and are committed to making a positive impact.