Protect What Matters: Discover Reliable Insurance Brokers in Sarasota, FL

Tired of searching for the right insurance broker in Sarasota, FL? We've got you covered! Our platform connects you with top-rated brokers specializing in business, home, and life insurance. Compare rates, save time, and rest assured you're in good hands.

Find insurance brokers near you
Warren Middleton State Farm Insurance is a full-service insurance agency serving Sarasota, Lakewood, and Bradenton, FL with a wide range of insurance and financial services, including auto, home, life, health, business, and recreational vehicle insurance, as well as banking and financial solutions.
The Warren Middleton Insurance Agency provides exceptional customer service, knowledgeable agents, and personalized attention, making clients feel valued and satisfied with their experience.
5.0
Based on 315 reviews
Profile Website Phone
At Morgan Insurance, we pride ourselves on providing personalized insurance services to our clients. Our team of experts will work with you to understand your specific insurance needs and provide tailored solutions to protect you and your loved ones. From auto and home insurance to flood and condominium insurance, we have you covered. Our experienced agents will take the time to explain everything to you in detail, giving you an overview of all the insurance coverages and advising you on your specific situations.
The reviews highlight the excellent customer service, knowledgeable agents, friendly and personalized approach of Morgan Insurance.
5.0
Based on 119 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Sarasota Health and Financial Services, Inc. is a family-owned and operated independent life and health insurance agency, providing personalized insurance solutions to individuals, families, and businesses in Sarasota and surrounding areas. With over 100 years of combined experience, our team of experts offers a wide range of insurance products and services, including individual major medical and group health insurance, Medicare supplements, Medicare Advantage plans, life insurance, annuities, and long-term care insurance.
The reviewers praised the company's exceptional service, patient explanation, and attention to detail.
5.0
Based on 1 review
Profile Website Phone
Atlas Insurance, an independent insurance agency, offers comprehensive insurance services to individuals and businesses of all sizes. With a focus on personalized service, our experienced team of insurance advocates designs and implements tailored insurance solutions to protect our clients' best interests.
Overall, reviewers praise Atlas Insurance for their excellent agents, exceptional customer service, and ability to find the best policies at competitive prices.
4.9
Based on 55 reviews
Profile Website Phone
The Peeples Insurance Agency focuses on personal and commercial insurance solutions tailored to suit our clients. With over 40 years of experience, our team has been representing families, businesses, and individuals across the state of Florida. We strive to maintain excellent customer service and provide the latest information to our clients. Our guiding principles have led us to the top of the insurance industry, enabling us to create custom plans that take all of our clients' needs into account. We are honored to provide personalized insurance solutions for each customer.
The majority of reviewers have had an extremely positive experience with Peeples Insurance, praising the staff's professionalism, responsiveness, and dedication to customer service.
A few reviewers have reported negative experiences, including un Returned phone calls, failure to receive quotes, and issues with policy changes and refunds.
4.8
Based on 238 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Jason Flatch State Farm Insurance is a local insurance agency in Sarasota, FL, offering a range of insurance products, including Auto, Motorcycle, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, and Pet insurance, as well as financial services and banking products. With over 80 years of combined experience, our team is dedicated to providing exceptional service and personalized attention to our customers.
Customers praise the agency for their professionalism, helpfulness, and friendly demeanor.
Some customers had difficulty reaching their agent and experienced poor service.
4.6
Based on 110 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Smith Insurance Group is an independent insurance agency dedicated to serving clients' insurance needs, including personal and commercial insurance products. With a wide range of insurance coverage options, personalized customer service, and a team of licensed agents, Smith Insurance Group is the one-stop shop for all insurance needs.
Many customers praised the agency's exceptional customer service and ability to find them the best rates on insurance.
A few customers experienced issues with non-renewal notices, policy cancellations, and poor service from specific agents.
4.3
Based on 25 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Leslie Jeffrey Insurance Agency is a local insurance agency serving the Sarasota, FL area. We offer a range of insurance services, including auto, home, and recreational vehicle insurance. Our expert agents will help you create a personalized insurance plan that meets your unique needs and budget. With years of experience and a deep understanding of the local market, we are dedicated to providing exceptional service and customer satisfaction.
The agency's friendly and helpful staff, efficient processing, and commitment to building long-term relationships made for a positive experience.
Despite some instances of poor service, including disrespect and errors, the agency has room for improvement in these areas.
4.2
Based on 48 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Michigan Commercial Insurance Mutual (MCIM) is a premier provider of workers' compensation insurance, offering coverage to virtually all industry groups in Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, and Michigan. For over thirty years, we have been committed to serving our policyholders through a distinguished group of independent agents. Originally founded as a self-insured group fund for builders and related trades, MCIM today provides an expanding range of programs and services to virtually all industry groups as a mutual insurance company.
Both reviews express frustration and disappointment with the company's communication and treatment of customers.
1.7
Based on 3 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Insurance Defenders is a dedicated team of professionals representing policyholders with claim disputes against their insurance carrier. They specialize in homeowners' and auto insurance claims, focusing on cases involving fire, hurricane, leaks, and more. Their team includes lawyers, doctors, roofers, renovators, HVAC, electricians, plumbers, drywall, painters, and more.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Ben Brown Insurance Agency, serving Southwest Florida, is a dedicated and experienced insurance broker that offers a wide range of insurance services for both commercial and personal needs. They specialize in providing customized insurance solutions for various industries, including construction, hospitality, manufacturing, self-storage, and wholesaler and distributor industries. With a focus on building long-term relationships and offering superior customer service, Ben Brown Insurance Agency ensures that all clients receive the best possible insurance coverage to protect their most valuable assets.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
MGildar Insurance is a Sarasota-based independent insurance agency providing personalized insurance services to individuals and families across the United States. Our experienced agent, Michael Gildar, specializes in life insurance, annuities, long-term care, and Medicare plans. With years of expertise in the industry, MGildar Insurance prides itself on delivering exceptional customer service, tailoring insurance solutions to meet individual needs. Whether in Sarasota, Florida, or nationwide, our goal is to provide the best insurance options for each client.
Reviewers overwhelmingly praise Michael Gildar's exceptional customer service, knowledge, and dedication, making him a top-notch insurance agent.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Wichert Insurance is a leading provider of personal, business insurance, and employee benefits to clients throughout Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Florida. With a wide range of quality, reliable insurance companies, they offer comprehensive insurance choices. Their approach includes a specialized four-step process to understand your business and help you identify, measure, insure, and control your risks. Wichert Insurance retains its legacy community-based relationships through its network of full-service agencies.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
For over 25 years, Team Focus Insurance Group has led the way in revolutionizing insurance operations, providing intuitive, easy-to-use SaaS-based Policy Management Solutions and services that drive profits for carriers and MGAs across the country. We're your one-stop-shop for all your underwriting and policy management needs, with a team of experienced professionals dedicated to helping you minimize exposure while maximizing profitability. Our innovative, flexible, cloud-based policy management system PolicyPort helps our customers manage underwriting in real-time, significantly improving their operating costs and maximizing their profitability.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
GreatFlorida Insurance is an insurance agency providing a range of insurance services, including homeowners, auto, boat, and commercial insurance. Our goal is to help individuals and businesses protect their assets and livelihoods with affordable and reliable insurance coverage. With a focus on customer service and expert guidance, we strive to make insurance easy and convenient for our clients.
The reviewers praise GreatFlorida Insurance for its excellent customer service, reasonable quotes, and easy transaction process.
However, one reviewer warns that the company's quotes may be significantly higher than those offered directly by insurance companies, leading to a negative experience.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Absolute Payroll is a Florida-based payroll and insurance service provider offering cost-effective solutions without compromising customer service. We provide payroll services, insurance options including workers' comp, liability, auto, and health, and human capital management. Our unique contractors program includes pay-as-you-go workers' comp, no minimum employees, and instant online certificates. We focus on building long-lasting relationships with our clients and offer personalized customer service.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Ideal Insurance is a fully licensed and insured independent insurance agency that works with a wide range of carriers to offer various types of insurance, including Auto, Homeowners, Umbrella, Commercial Property, and more. With a team of highly experienced agents, we help individuals and businesses find insurance policies that meet their specific needs without exceeding their budget. Our agency is family-owned and operated, serving clients in Sarasota, Manatee County, and surrounding areas. We pride ourselves on providing personalized service and addressing customer concerns in a timely manner. With 99% of our clients choosing to renew their policies with us, you can trust that Ideal Insurance is here to help you get the right protection for your needs at the lowest cost.
The reviewer Connie Ragusa had a positive experience with the company, praising its friendly and knowledgeable staff.
The reviewer Julie C. experienced poor service, including incompetence, poor recommendations, and difficulty with account management.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Shapiro Insurance Group, a Division of Patriot Growth Insurance Services, LLC, provides a wide range of insurance services including Home Owners, Renters, Flood, Fire, Umbrella, Auto, Boat/Watercraft, Motorcycle, RV, ATV, Classic Car, Business Insurance, Commercial Liability, Commercial Auto, Professional Liability, Workers Comp, Life Insurance, Term Life, Whole Life, Disability Income, Health Insurance, Dental Insurance, and Policy Transfers.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Bradenton (11.5 mi) Ellenton (12.8 mi) Venice (17.0 mi) Parrish (18.5 mi) North Port (27.1 mi) Ruskin (27.2 mi) Englewood (28.1 mi) Sun City Center (28.5 mi) Saint Petersburg (29.3 mi) Apollo Beach (31.1 mi)