Tom Plummer Agency, an independent insurance agency, has been dedicated to overseeing the insurance needs of individuals and businesses in Indiana for many years. Our agency, established in 1949 by Tom Plummer, has been built on the foundation of exceptional service, personalized options, and trustworthy relationships.
For over six decades, our mission has been to improve the insurance experience by offering personalized solutions for individuals, families, and businesses. We aim to provide personal service and convenience, as well as affordable coverage that simplifies today's overwhelming insurance market. At Tom Plummer Agency, we understand the importance of tailored coverage for each client, and our team is committed to taking the time needed to ensure proper and adequate insurance coverage when you need it most.
Our agency has grown over the years, starting with Tom Plummer as a sole proprietor and expanding to include three generations of the Plummer family. Our experienced and knowledgeable team consists of Scott Plummer, who joined the agency in 1976, Julia Lang, joining in 2003, and Molly Plummer, the latest addition to the family business after her graduation from the University of Indianapolis.
Personal Insurance Services
We take pride in offering a wide range of personal insurance options to our clients, including:
- Homeowners insurance
- Automobile insurance
- Mobile home insurance
- Renters / Condo insurance
- Boat / Motorcycle insurance
- Umbrella insurance
- Dwelling/Fire insurance
- Classic Car insurance
Our team is dedicated to finding the best coverage for each client, comparing rates and options from our wide network of insurance carriers. We understand the unique needs of Indiana residents and offer personalized solutions that offer protection and peace of mind.
Commercial Insurance Services
In addition to personal insurance options, we also specialize in commercial insurance for Indiana business owners:
- Business owner policy
- Commercial auto insurance
- Commercial property insurance
- Commercial umbrella insurance
- General liability insurance
- Professional liability insurance
- Workers' compensation insurance
- Contractors liability insurance
- Life and Short term medical plans
We cater to the insurance needs of businesses of all sizes and industries in Indiana. Our experienced agents are committed to finding the most comprehensive coverage at competitive rates.
Why Choose Tom Plummer Agency?
At Tom Plummer Agency, we consistently deliver value, a range of options, and personalized service to our clients throughout Indiana. Our knowledgeable agents are dedicated to staying informed on the latest coverage options and remain committed to offering you the most affordable rates. We offer convenient claims and payment methods, including automatic payment and withdrawal, simplified reporting for claims.
Choose Tom Plummer Agency for peace of mind and the confidence of knowing that your personal or commercial insurance needs are being handled by a trusted and experienced agency.
Family-Focused Service
The Tom Plummer Agency has been serving their clients for over 50 years, with a family-like atmosphere that has been maintained across generations. The agency's founders, Tom and Steve, as well as Steve's successor Scott, have all been dedicated to providing excellent service and high standards. Even in the face of adversity, such as Scott's brutal beating in a robbery attempt, the agency has continued to thrive under his leadership and now under his daughter Maggie's guidance.
Mixed Experience
However, not all clients have had a positive experience with the agency. One reviewer, Anessa, had a problematic experience with her car and homeowner's insurance policies. Despite numerous rate increases, she never received a call or notice from the agency. When she tried to address the issue, she was met with a lack of professional courtesy, with the agent telling her to check other rates.
Praise for Competency and Value
Other reviewers have had a more positive experience with the Tom Plummer Agency. Brian Biehn praised the agency's courtesy, competency, and delivery of value. Cassandra Jones, who has been a client for over 15 years, has consistently received prompt and professional service from the agency. She was particularly impressed with Molly's ability to address a complex issue with her insurance policy, going above and beyond to ensure that everything worked out.
Be the first to review Tom Plummer & Sons.
Write a Review
