Get Quotes Contact Us My Profile Add Your Business

Protect What Matters: Discover Reliable Insurance Brokers in Indianapolis, IN

Tired of searching for the right insurance broker in Indianapolis, IN? We've got you covered! Our platform connects you with top-rated brokers specializing in business, home, and life insurance. Compare rates, save time, and rest assured you're in good hands.

Find insurance brokers near you
Kyle Hale

Kyle Hale

kyleismyagent.com
Hale Insurance and Financial Services Inc is a State Farm insurance agency located in Indianapolis, Indiana, offering a wide range of insurance products, including auto, home, renters, condo, life, health, and business insurance. The agency is dedicated to providing exceptional service, educating clients about the importance of having the right insurance plan, and helping them prepare for the future. With over 40+ years of combined experience, the team is committed to building lifelong relationships and delivering unparalleled service.
The reviews overwhelmingly praise the insurance office for their exceptional customer service, knowledgeable agents, and personalized approach.
5.0
Based on 185 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Multi Line Insurance

Multi Line Insurance

multi-lineins.com
Multiline Insurance Agency is a trusted insurance brokerage firm providing a wide range of insurance services to individuals and businesses. Our team of experts helps clients navigate the complex world of insurance, offering personalized solutions for their unique needs. With access to over 20 insurance companies, we shop around to find the best rates and coverage for our clients. Whether you need home, auto, motorcycle, boat, or business insurance, we've got you covered.
The reviewers praise the agency's exceptional customer service, personalized approach, reliability, and quick response time.
5.0
Based on 36 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Brittany Wells

Brittany Wells

mywellsinsurance.com
We are a State Farm Agency, providing insurance services for auto, homeowners, condo, renters, business, life, health, and pet insurance. We offer personalized quotes and provide guidance and assistance with insurance transfers. Our team is dedicated to building long-lasting relationships with our customers, considering them as family. We provide outstanding service and protection to help our customers achieve their life goals.
The reviewers praised the agency's exceptional customer service, willingness to go above and beyond, and professional and helpful agents.
4.9
Based on 286 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Kellie Taylor

Kellie Taylor

weinsureindy.com
Kellie Taylor State Farm Agency is a dedicated insurance agency offering a range of insurance products, including auto, homeowners, condo, renters, life, health, and business insurance. With over 18 years of experience in the industry, Kellie Taylor, the agency owner, is passionate about helping her community manage the risks of everyday life, recover from the unexpected, and achieve their dreams. The agency provides free quotes, free insurance and financial service reviews, and supports local charities through its "Quotels for Good" program.
The majority of reviewers have had a positive experience with Kellie Taylor and her team, praising their professionalism, knowledge, and customer service.
A few reviewers have had negative experiences, citing issues with policy and billing problems.
4.9
Based on 195 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Jim Metzler, Agent

Jim Metzler, Agent

insuranceinindy.com
Jim Metzler State Farm Insurance is a family-owned business providing insurance and financial services to individuals and businesses in the Greater Indianapolis Area. With over 40 years of experience, they specialize in Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet, and Pet Insurance. They also offer banking and mutual funds services. Their team of licensed insurance agents is dedicated to helping customers get the right insurance coverage for their needs and budget.
The reviewers praise Jim Metzler's agency for their exceptional customer service, policy reviews, expertise, and loyalty to clients.
The only negative comment is Larry Freiburger's brief review, where he does not specify any issues.
4.9
Based on 72 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Shelly Wynn

Shelly Wynn

shellywynn.com
The Shelly Wynn State Farm Insurance office is proud to serve Indianapolis, Franklin Township, and surrounding Indiana areas with Auto Insurance, Home Insurance, Renter's Insurance, Life Insurance, Business Insurance and Financial Services. We are a family of highly skilled individuals working together to fulfill a community responsibility of giving outstanding service and also fulfilling our moral obligation of protecting what's important to customer's so they can focus on accomplishing their life goals. My team of licensed Insurance Professionals is here to help get you Insurance coverage for your specific needs. Not only can we help with Car Insurance, Homeowners Insurance, Life Insurance and Financial Services, but we are also able to assist small business owners with their Commercial lines of Insurance.
The reviewers highly praise the agency's exceptional customer service, expert advice, and welcoming atmosphere, making it an excellent choice for insurance needs.
4.9
Based on 14 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Connie Mortensen

Connie Mortensen

connieismyagent.com
Connie Mortensen State Farm is a State Farm insurance agent in the Southport area of Indianapolis, Indiana. With over 40 years of combined team experience in auto insurance, home insurance, business insurance, pet insurance, and life insurance, we are dedicated to protecting our community and forming strong relationships with our clients. We offer a variety of insurance products, including auto, homeowners, condo, renters, personal articles, business, life, health, and pet insurance, as well as banking and mutual funds. Our goal is to make our community better every day.
The staff's friendly and knowledgeable nature, along with the office's excellent customer service and competitive pricing, make State Farm a top choice for customers.
4.8
Based on 120 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Binford Insurance

Binford Insurance

binfordinsurance.com
Binford Insurance is a full-service insurance agency located in Indianapolis, Indiana, and serving the surrounding suburbs. Our experienced agents specialize in providing personalized coverage for individuals, contractors, retailers, and homeowners. We offer a wide range of insurance products, including car insurance, home insurance, umbrella insurance, motorcycle insurance, and more. Our goal is to provide exceptional service and tailored coverage to meet the unique needs of our clients.
The reviews highlight the agency's excellent service, professionalism, and customer-oriented approach.
However, one reviewer experienced significant issues with the agency's handling of their policy and communication, leading to negative outcomes.
4.8
Based on 62 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Brenda Bond

Brenda Bond

teambrendabond.com
Our agency offers a wide range of insurance products and services, including auto, homeowners, condo, renters, personal articles, business, life, health, and pet insurance. We also provide banking and mutual fund services. Our team of agents has a combined 65 years of experience and is dedicated to helping our clients make informed insurance decisions. We offer personalized quotes, and our agents are available to assist with all insurance needs, including claims and policy management.
The overall positive comments highlight the exceptional customer service, professionalism, and prompt and efficient service provided by the agents at State Farm.
4.7
Based on 67 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Stacey Hamilton

Stacey Hamilton

staceyhamilton.net
Stacey Hamilton Ins Agcy Inc is a State Farm insurance agency providing auto, homeowners, condo, renters, personal articles, business, life, health, and pet insurance products. We also offer banking and mutual funds. Our agency is located in Indianapolis, Indiana, and serves the surrounding areas of Beech Grove, Greenwood, Zionsville, and Carmel. Our mission is to assist our customers in preparing for the future by providing personalized insurance coverage and exceptional customer service. With a team of knowledgeable agents, we strive to build lasting relationships with individuals, families, and businesses in our community.
State Farm is praised for its exceptional staff, personalized customer service, and competitive insurance rates.
One customer expresses dissatisfaction with the company's honesty and transparency regarding their bundle program.
4.7
Based on 34 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Ross Whitfield

Ross Whitfield

thewhitfieldagency.com
With over 20 years of industry experience and 14 years as a State Farm agent, Ross Whitfield and his team provide insurance services, including home, car, renters, life, and business insurance. As a respected resource for real estate investors, the agency is located in downtown Indianapolis and serves the entire state of Indiana.
Many customers have praised the agency's staff for their knowledge, helpfulness, and professionalism.
Some customers have experienced frustration with the claim process, miscommunication, and poor customer service, leading to a switch to a different agency.
4.6
Based on 32 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Oldham Insurance Agency

Oldham Insurance Agency

oldhaminsured.com
Oldham Insurance Agency can help you navigate the complex world of insurance plans because we are independent agents with a commitment to tailoring insurance coverage to our customers' needs. Our agents use a consultative approach in finding the best coverage to match your lifestyle. We take great pride in educating and assisting our clients on the complex world of insurance, and making sure that we are doing what we can to keep them as customers and clients for life. At the Oldham Insurance Agency, we don't want you to just buy insurance, we want you to be Oldham Insured. We are proud to have been serving the Indianapolis community and the insurance industry since the mid 1950's.
Reviewers praise Oldham Insurance for its excellent service, knowledgeable agents, and professionalism.
The company is criticized for being more expensive than other providers for the same coverage.
4.4
Based on 11 reviews
Profile Website Phone
United Home Life

United Home Life

unitedhomelife.com
United Home Life Insurance Company is a leading provider of life insurance products, offering a range of coverage options to individuals and families. With a simplified process that eliminates the need for medical exams and lengthy applications, our policies provide peace of mind and financial protection to loved ones in the event of a tragic event. We strive to deliver excellent customer service and provide straightforward products that meet the specific needs of our clients. Whether you're looking for whole life, term life, or accidental death insurance, we have a solution that's right for you.
Customers praised the professionalism, knowledge, and services of the company's representatives, as well as the cleanliness and friendly atmosphere of the facilities.
Many customers reported poor communication, incompetent customer service, and even unauthorized transactions, leading to frustration and dissatisfaction with the company's services.
4.1
Based on 50 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Indiana Automobile Insurance

Indiana Automobile Insurance

indianafairplan.com
The Indiana FAIR Plan is a voluntary association that provides property insurance to Indiana residents who have been declined coverage by at least three non-related insurance companies. We offer dwelling and commercial insurance with maximum coverage limits of $250,000 and $1,000,000, respectively. Our online application system makes it easy to apply and manage your policy. We are committed to providing basic property insurance to those who need it most.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Midwest Insurance Marketers Of America

Midwest Insurance Marketers Of America

mwima.com
Midwest Insurance Marketers of America is a Managing General Agency founded in Indianapolis, Indiana, with over 30 years of experience in the Group and Individual Medical, Life, Disability, and Senior Product brokerage arena. We provide support for independent insurance agents to grow and expand their business through service, support, and product information. Our team, led by Lori Garman, Holly Fisher, Christy Hopper, and Nikki Carlisle, are dedicated to providing excellent service and resolving coverage issues for our clients.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Tom Plummer & Sons

Tom Plummer & Sons

tomplummeragency.com
Tom Plummer Agency is a reputable insurance agency that has been serving Indiana for over 60 years. With a focus on personalized service, the agency offers a wide range of insurance policies, including home, auto, commercial, life, and short-term medical insurance. The agency's agents work closely with clients to analyze their insurance needs and provide expert recommendations to ensure they have the right coverage. The agency is committed to staying informed about new and existing coverage options and provides convenient claims and payment methods to simplify the insurance process.
The Tom Plummer Agency is known for its excellent service, family-like atmosphere, and high standards.
However, some clients have experienced poor customer service and lack of professionalism.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
DMC Insurance

DMC Insurance

dmcinsurance.com
DMC Insurance is a leading trucking insurance company that specializes in providing comprehensive solutions for trucking businesses. Our team of experts offers world-class claims handling, risk engineering, and data science services to help our clients navigate the complexities of the trucking industry. With a focus on partnering with our clients, we strive to deliver personalized service and tailor-made solutions to meet their unique needs. Our claims team is proactive in resolving claims quickly and cost-effectively, while our risk engineers work closely with clients to identify and mitigate risks.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website
Sullivan John

Sullivan John

mcgowaninsgrp.com
McGowan Insurance Group is an independent agency that offers a wide range of insurance products and services. We have excellent relationships with high-level insurance providers, allowing us to customize programs to meet the needs of any business. Our advisors have decades of experience and serve as your advocate from analyzing and determining coverage options to filing a claim.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Wilson Family Insurance Agency

Wilson Family Insurance Agency

wilsonfamilyinsurance.com
Wilson Family Insurance is a family-owned and operated insurance agency that specializes in auto, home, and business insurance. With over 60 years of professional experience, our team provides complete insurance solutions at the most affordable prices to secure the financial well-being of our community members. We serve individuals, families, and businesses in Indianapolis and all of Central Indiana. Our services extend beyond insurance to include volunteer work with local organizations and individuals to develop the community socially and economically. We focus on one-on-one attention to our customers and go the extra mile to deliver the best coverage and the best price.
Wilson Insurance is praised for its exceptional customer service, competitive rates, and personalized approach.
One customer had a negative experience with a denied claim and unauthorized account withdrawals.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Conner Insurance

Conner Insurance

connerins.com
Conner Insurance is a family-owned business with over 70 years of experience in providing comprehensive commercial, personal, and benefits insurance solutions. Our team of trusted insurance advisors offers a wide range of valuable insurance products and services to individuals and businesses in all 50 U.S. states. We understand the importance of protecting our clients' assets, families, and employees, and we strive to make the insurance process simple and effective. With our robust insurance solutions, we can help reduce risk, maximize company culture, and provide valuable benefit plans that protect employees and their families.
Ashley Brown and Conner Insurance provide exceptional customer service, expert insurance guidance, and cost-effective solutions, earning numerous five-star reviews.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Mc Pike Insurance Service

Mc Pike Insurance Service

mcpikeinsurance.com
McPike Insurance Agency is a full-service insurance agency providing personalized guidance and support for health, life, and financial needs. We offer Medicare Planning, Dental, Vision, and Hearing coverage, Life and Disability insurance, Long-term Care insurance, and Retirement and Financial Planning. Since 1974, we have been dedicated to exceptional customer service and building long-term relationships with our clients.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Weaver & Sokol

Weaver & Sokol

weavgrp.com
Weaver Insurance Group is an independent insurance agency representing A-rated insurance carriers. As an independent agency, we take pride in our consultative approach, taking the time to understand your changing insurance needs and putting a personal insurance or business insurance program in place that delivers economy, superior protection, and risk management assistance. Whether you need personal insurance for cars, homes, boats, life, health, and RV, or business insurance for your small or large business, Weaver Insurance Group is your source. We can help you find the right coverage to protect your family, home, and business.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
State Farm Insurance

State Farm Insurance

myindysf.com
The John Elbin State Farm Agency is a premier insurance agency providing a wide range of insurance products and services, including auto, homeowners, condo, renters, business, life, health, pet, and more. With years of experience, we strive to assist residents relocating to the Indianapolis, IN area, as well as insuring all of Central Indiana. We focus on providing competitive prices and exceptional service to our customers. With a strong commitment to our community, we are proud to be one of the top agencies in Indiana.
All reviewers praised the agency for providing exceptional customer service, knowledgeable agents, and competitive insurance rates.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
H J Spier

H J Spier

hjspier.com
H.J. Spier Co Inc is a premier insurance and financial management business founded in 1930 by Herbert J Spier, Sr. We offer a wide variety of insurance products and services dedicated to bringing important value to the needs of our customers. Our comprehensive analysis of the insurance marketplace and excellent relationships with our insurance companies are integral parts of designing and implementing custom insurance programs. For over 85 years, H.J. Spier Co Inc has been committed to protecting the assets of its customers. From personal to business and professional exposures, you can look to us with confidence for advice, product, and customer service.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Colliver Insurance

Colliver Insurance

colliverins.com
Colliver Insurance, established in 1999, is a full-service agency offering auto, home, life, business, and health insurance. With a team of licensed professionals, they provide quotes through reputable insurance companies to find the best rates for clients. Located in Indianapolis, they serve clients across Indiana and pride themselves on excellent customer service, claim assistance, and accessibility through various channels.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Sterling Investors Life Insurance

Sterling Investors Life Insurance

sterlinglifeco.com
Sterling Investors Life Insurance Company has been providing quality life and health insurance products for over 30 years. They offer a variety of products including life insurance, annuity products, Medicare Supplement Insurance, Convalescent Care Insurance, and Cancer Indemnity Insurance. With a focus on providing affordable insurance solutions, they aim to give customers and their loved ones peace and security for their financial planning.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
I 2 Advisors

I 2 Advisors

lsa-llc.com
Life Settlement Advisors is a reputable insurance broker with over 40 years of combined experience, offering life settlement and viatical settlement services. They help individuals and advisors understand the process of selling a life insurance policy, providing sound advice and education. Their goal is to provide a legitimate alternative to surrendering policies, helping clients make informed decisions.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Jensen Gerald L Insurance

Jensen Gerald L Insurance

jensenfordinsurance.com
Jensen Ford Insurance Agency is a leading independent insurance agency specializing in providing personalized insurance solutions to individuals and businesses. Our team of expert insurance professionals is dedicated to helping our clients navigate the complex world of insurance, offering a wide range of coverage options including auto, home, life, health, and commercial insurance. With a commitment to customer service, we strive to keep your insurance experience simple and provide comprehensive, modern coverage. Our team is always available to answer your questions and provide guidance on the best insurance options for your unique situation.
Jensen Ford Insurance is praised for its friendly, efficient, and honest service.
One customer experienced a delay in receiving a refund and felt the agent did not provide sufficient assistance.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Indiana Insurance Department

Indiana Insurance Department

lifeinsurancehub.net
Life Insurance Hub is a dedicated service to help you understand life insurance quotes and how to apply them to your personal financial needs. It's a platform where you can get detailed information on the best available life insurance policies and quotes from highly reputable life insurance companies.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Carter Insurance

Carter Insurance

ecarterinsurance.com
Carter Insurance Agency, LLC offers comprehensive insurance solutions tailored to meet your personal and commercial needs. With a focus on exceptional customer service, we provide a wide range of insurance products including Personal Lines Insurance, Commercial Lines Insurance, and more. Our experienced team is dedicated to helping you protect the most precious things in your life.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Steffey Insurance Agency

Steffey Insurance Agency

steffeyins.com
Steffey Insurance has over 40 years of experience in providing a wide range of insurance options to its customers. With a focus on customer service, they work with countless carriers to provide coverage that meets each client's unique needs. From auto insurance to business insurance, and beyond, Steffey Insurance has the products and knowledge to back it up. With a presence in 12 states, they are committed to delivering first-class service to all their clients.
The majority of reviewers praised the exceptional customer service and support provided by Steffey Insurance Agency's agents.
One reviewer had a negative experience with the agency, citing unprofessional behavior and poor communication.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Greenwood (11.0 mi) Avon (12.8 mi) Plainfield (13.6 mi) Brownsburg (13.7 mi) Zionsville (13.7 mi) Carmel (14.6 mi) Fishers (15.1 mi) Mooresville (15.7 mi) Westfield (19.0 mi) Fairland (20.1 mi)