Website Call now
Website
Call

Protecting Your Business, Empowering Your Future

A Legacy of Protecting Hoosiers Since the 1950s

The Oldham Insurance Agency carries the legacy of the Oldham family in Indiana. Founded on values of integrity, expertise, and personalized service, we've been serving the community for over 60 years. In 2012, Donald Oldham, III proudly established our independent agency, upholding the tradition of empowering clients with tailored insurance solutions.

Building Custom Coverage with You in Mind

Our team of experienced professionals goes beyond simply selling insurance. We take the time to understand your unique needs, risks, and aspirations to create a comprehensive insurance plan that aligns with your life stage and goals. We are your trusted partners, committed to:

  • Understanding your individual needs: We listen carefully to your concerns and aspirations to identify potential risks.
  • Finding the right coverage: With access to several major insurance carriers, we can offer competitive plans from reputable companies.
  • Personalized attention: You'll work directly with a dedicated agent who will guide you through the process and answer your questions.
  • Educating clients: We believe in empowering our clients with knowledge and guidance to make informed decisions about their insurance.

Comprehensive Coverage for Every Need

From protecting your personal belongings to ensuring the financial stability of your business, we offer a comprehensive range of insurance products, including:

  • Personal Insurance: Home, Auto, Life, Umbrella
  • Commercial Insurance: Business owners, Workers' Compensation, General Liability
  • Life Insurance: Term Life, Whole Life

Peace of Mind, Guaranteed

At Oldham Insurance Agency, our mission is to provide you with peace of mind knowing that you are adequately protected. We are committed to transparency, responsiveness, and personalized service every step of the way.

Please contact us today to request a personalized quote and experience the Oldham Insurance Agency difference.
Reviews (11)
Write a Review
Positive: Reviewers praise Oldham Insurance for its excellent service, knowledgeable agents, and professionalism.
Negative: The company is criticized for being more expensive than other providers for the same coverage.

Overview of Reviews

The reviews for Oldham Insurance are overwhelmingly positive, with 6 out of 7 reviewers giving a 5-star rating. The majority of reviewers praise the company's excellent service, knowledgeable agents, and professional communication.

Positive Comments

Responsive and Knowledgeable Agents

Reviewers rave about the company's responsive and knowledgeable agents, who provide clear explanations and work with clients to find the best coverage.

Excellent Service and Professionalism

Oldham Insurance is commended for its excellent service, strong integrity, and total commitment to its clients. Reviewers appreciate the company's professionalism, timely communication, and ability to find affordable coverage.

Access to Variety of Insurance Options

The company is also praised for its access to a range of insurance companies, including lesser-known providers that can offer more competitive rates.

Negative Comments

Cost Comparability

The only negative review cites that Oldham Insurance is more expensive than other companies for the same coverage from the same carrier.