Protect What Matters: Discover Reliable Insurance Brokers in Evansville, IN

Tired of searching for the right insurance broker in Evansville, IN? We've got you covered! Our platform connects you with top-rated brokers specializing in business, home, and life insurance. Compare rates, save time, and rest assured you're in good hands.

Find insurance brokers near you
Southern Insurance Agency is a full-service insurance agency providing a wide range of insurance products and services to the local community. Our experienced agents, led by Brian Southern, are dedicated to providing personalized service and innovative solutions for your insurance needs. We offer a variety of insurance products, including auto, homeowners, condo, renters, business, life, health, pet, and recreational vehicle insurance. Our team is committed to helping you make informed decisions about your insurance coverage and providing exceptional customer service.
The majority of reviewers had a positive experience with this insurance agency, praising their excellent customer service, competitive pricing, and willingness to help.
One reviewer had a very negative experience with a discount program that failed to deliver as promised.
5.0
Based on 188 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Randy Robertson State Farm is a locally owned and operated insurance agency in Evansville, IN, offering a wide range of insurance products, including Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Business, Life, Health, Pet, and Recreational Vehicles insurance. With over 36 years of experience, our team provides personalized service and tailored solutions to protect your assets and loved ones.
The reviewers praised the agency's exceptional customer service, prompt response, personalized attention, and proactive recommendations.
5.0
Based on 125 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Tri-State Insurance Group is a trusted and experienced insurance agency located in Evansville, Indiana. We provide a wide range of insurance services, including life, auto, home, business, and more. Our agents are knowledgeable and dedicated to helping our clients find the right coverage for their needs. With over 90 years of combined insurance experience, we are committed to providing excellent service and competitive rates to our clients. We are proud to be a family-owned and operated business, now in its fourth generation. Whether you're looking for a quote, policy review, or have a question about your insurance, we're here to help.
The reviewers praised the exceptional customer service, competitive pricing, personalized approach, and knowledgeable agents at Tri-State Insurance Group.
5.0
Based on 26 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Newbury Financial is a senior insurance benefits agency that specializes in offering a range of insurance products to seniors in Indiana and Kentucky. As an independent insurance broker, we offer a range of insurance plans from leading companies, allowing our clients to choose from a variety of options tailored to their needs. Our experienced agents take the time to understand our clients' insurance needs and work hard to secure the best rates for their insurance policies. Our services include Medicare supplements, long-term care insurance, life insurance, and annuities. With over
The company is known for its knowledgeable, honest, and excellent service, offering the best insurance and financial products and advice.
5.0
Based on 1 review
Profile Website Phone
Brunson Insurance Agency Inc. is a full-service insurance agency offering a wide range of insurance products, including auto, homeowners, condo, renters, personal articles, business, and life insurance. The agency serves the Evansville and Newburgh, IN area, focusing on residence relocations and providing free quotes in auto, home, renter, and life insurance. With over 4.9-star rating on Google, the agency is dedicated to helping families and individuals protect their assets and secure their future. With expert advice and personalized service, the agency helps clients navigate the complex world of insurance to find the right coverage for their unique needs. With offices in Evansville, IN, the agency is committed to providing exceptional service and ensuring that clients are well-protected from unexpected events.
The agency's staff are praised for their professionalism, friendliness, and helpfulness, making clients feel informed and confident.
4.9
Based on 123 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Torian Insurance is a family-owned and operated insurance agency that has been providing tried and trusted insurance solutions to the community for over 90 years. With a commitment to personalized service and customized insurance portfolios, Torian Insurance offers a wide range of insurance products and services, including personal and commercial insurance, employee benefits, and specialty insurance. With a passion for getting to know each client and understanding their unique needs, Torian Insurance takes pride in delivering exceptional service and ensuring that clients are protected and cared for.
The reviews highlight the exceptional customer service, efficient claims handling, and personalized service provided by Torian Insurance.
One reviewer reported a negative experience due to a lack of understanding by one agent.
4.9
Based on 78 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Double Eagle Insurance is an independent insurance agency providing personalized insurance solutions for individuals and businesses in Evansville, IN and Newburgh, IN. From home insurance to business insurance, employee benefits, and more, our team is dedicated to finding the right coverage for our clients. We believe in thinking outside the box to provide innovative insurance solutions.
Staff members were praised for their professionalism, responsiveness, and efficiency in handling claims.
Concerns about the company's integrity, poor communication, and misleading information were expressed, leading to negative experiences with insurance policies and claims.
4.2
Based on 19 reviews
Profile Website Phone
McElya & Associates Insurance Group, Inc. is a renowned insurance brokerage firm providing Medicare Supplement, Health Insurance, and Life Insurance solutions to individuals and families in Evansville, Indiana, and Fort Wayne, Indiana and surrounding areas. With a team of experienced agents, we strive to provide personalized service and simplified insurance solutions to meet the diverse needs of our clients. We specialize in helping seniors navigate the complicated world of senior healthcare insurance, including Medicare Supplements, Medicare Advantage, and under-65 medical insurance. Our goal is to provide peace of mind by helping our clients make informed decisions about their insurance options.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Schultheis Insurance is a well-established independent insurance agency located in Evansville, IN, serving Greenwood, Mt. Vernon, Newburgh, and surrounding areas. As an independent agency, we partner with over 150 insurance providers to offer our customers great, cost-effective rates on personal insurance and commercial insurance products, from auto insurance to group health insurance plans. With over 70 years of experience, we've passed the tests of quality and price, and we've been there for our customers when they needed us. We're building relationships and learning about you, our clients.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Abbey Insurance & Tax Services is a full-service agency specializing in providing benefits and insurance solutions to the beauty industry. With over 30 years of experience, we offer a wide range of products and services, including employee and association group benefits, personal and commercial insurance, life and health insurance, disability income protection plans, and tax solutions. Our team, led by Kelvin M. Brett, is dedicated to providing exceptional service and personalized attention to each client. We are licensed in every state and DC, except for Hawaii, and are proud to be the recommended benefits administrator for several industry associations.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
At Archer Insurance, we're here to help you navigate the world of insurance with ease. As a premier insurance brokerage, we represent a wide range of insurance companies, offering you many comprehensive coverage options at various price points. Our independent status allows us to shop the market for you without being beholden to a big carrier, saving you money without ever sacrificing quality coverage. Our team of experts is dedicated to understanding your insurance needs and providing you with a quote to help you evaluate the market before switching. With our help, you can shop vetted policies from over 30 insurance carriers, ensuring you get the best coverage for your dollar. We're committed to exceeding expectations with ease, providing a seamless experience from start to finish.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Newburgh (9.2 mi) Henderson (9.4 mi) Morganfield (27.4 mi) Owensboro (28.6 mi)