Protect What Matters: Discover Reliable Insurance Brokers in Tallahassee, FL

Tired of searching for the right insurance broker in Tallahassee, FL? We've got you covered! Our platform connects you with top-rated brokers specializing in business, home, and life insurance. Compare rates, save time, and rest assured you're in good hands.

Find insurance brokers near you
McGinniss Himmel Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency that provides quality coverage tailored to fit your needs and budget. We focus on educating our clients about their options while providing individualized, experienced, and local guidance along with unique solutions to help our clients recover from life's unexpected events. With access to several of the largest and most respected companies, we are confident we can find coverage that matches your described needs at a competitive rate.
The reviews highlight exceptional service, expertise, and personalized approach to insurance needs.
5.0
Based on 865 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Premier Insurance Agency is a full service Independent Insurance Agency. We represent a wide variety of insurance companies to offer you more choices of companies and coverages for your insurance dollars. We know you are busy so you can expect convenience when you work with our agency. We do the shopping for you so you don't have to! We take your information one time, and use that information to get offers from the interested insurance companies. This saves you the hassle of making multiple phone calls to multiple agents. You can rest assured knowing we are doing the work for you. Our service can also provide you with help with your life insurance and financial planning needs. Please call our office or send us a message. We would love the opportunity to walk you through your coverage options at Premier Insurance Agency.
All reviewers had a positive experience with Shanna and Premier Insurance Agency, praising her professionalism, friendliness, and expertise.
5.0
Based on 55 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Pichard Insurance Agency, Inc. is an independent insurance agency serving Tallahassee, FL, and the surrounding counties of Gadsden, Jefferson, Leon, and Wakulla since 1970. As an independent insurance agency, we represent different insurance companies, enabling you to compare coverage options and prices before buying. Whether you are shopping for home insurance, car insurance, business insurance, church insurance, or a package of insurance policies, we can help find the right policy for you. We offer Auto Insurance, Commercial and Business Insurance, Liability, Workers Comp Insurance, and Short Term Rental and Home Insurance. Pichard Insurance Agency, Inc. provides insurance services to Crawfordville, Havana, Monticello, Quincy, Tallahassee, FL, and the surrounding areas.
The reviews praise the agency's helpful, friendly, and professional staff, as well as its long-term relationships with clients.
5.0
Based on 8 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Waterhouse Insurance & Financial Services specializes in auto insurance in Tallahassee and is a leader in providing quality discount insurance protection for hundreds of individuals, families and businesses throughout Tallahassee and the state of Florida. Providing superior insurance coverage and customer service at low rates along with our ability to understand our customer's insurance coverage and financial needs in Tallahassee FL, drives the success of our agency. By offering world class auto insurance in Tallahassee and protection for your Auto Insurance, Home Insurance, Commercial Insurance, General Liability Insurance, Recreational Insurance in Tallahassee, we make sure that you're covered today as well as in the future so that you can focus on what is important to you and your family.
The reviews highlight the positive experiences of many customers, who appreciated the helpfulness and professionalism of the representatives they dealt with, and who would recommend the company to others.
The reviews also highlight the negative experiences of some customers, who experienced poor service, long wait times, and issues with policy cancellations.
4.9
Based on 1,253 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Bill Reardon Ins Agcy Inc is a State Farm Insurance Agent providing insurance services to Tallahassee and all of Florida. We offer free quotes for Auto, Home, Renters, and Life insurance. Our team of experts is dedicated to providing excellent service to our customers. With over 26 years of experience, we strive for excellence every day.
The reviewers praised the agency's exceptional customer service, expertise, and professionalism, making it a highly recommended insurance provider.
4.9
Based on 306 reviews
Profile Website Phone
At Nate DeGraaf State Farm Agency, we pride ourselves on educating, servicing, and protecting our customers. With 22 years of experience as a State Farm Agent, Nate DeGraaf has built a reputation for providing top-notch insurance services to individuals and businesses across Florida. Our agency earned the coveted Chairman Circle Award in 2023, a testament to our commitment to excellence.
The reviewers praised the excellent customer service, professionalism, and responsiveness of the office staff and agents.
One reviewer had a negative experience with an unprofessional agent who was inconsistent with billing and showed bias.
4.9
Based on 93 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Kingdom Tree Insurance Group offers a variety of personal and business insurance solutions to help individuals and businesses protect what matters most. With a focus on providing exceptional customer service and personalized support, the agency serves clients in Tallahassee, Florida, and beyond. From personal insurance options like home, auto, and umbrella insurance, to business insurance solutions such as general liability, errors and omissions, and business owners insurance, Kingdom Tree Insurance Group has the expertise and resources to meet the unique needs of each client. With multiple carrier partnerships and a commitment to transparency, the agency helps clients make informed decisions about their insurance coverage. By choosing Kingdom Tree Insurance Group, clients can trust that they are receiving the best possible service and coverage.
Reviewers have praised the company's excellent rates, coverage, and customer service, with many noting that they were able to save money on their premiums and received personalized service.
One reviewer had a disappointing experience with the company, stating that the representative they spoke to did not listen to their concerns and asked unnecessary questions.
4.9
Based on 58 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Smallridge Ins and Fin Svc Inc is a full-service insurance agency providing auto, homeowners, condo, renters, business, life, and health insurance products to individuals and businesses in the Tallahassee, FL area. The agency serves Crawfordville, Monticello, Havana, Quincy, and Woodville, FL, as well as Leon, Gadsden, Jefferson, and Wakulla counties. With a team of experienced agents, the agency offers personalized quotes, answers phone calls 24/7, and has extended office hours Monday to Friday.
The reviews are filled with praise for the exceptional customer service, knowledgeable agents, and competitive rates and coverage offered by the agency.
4.8
Based on 183 reviews
Profile Website Phone
McKee Insurance Agency is a trusted insurance agency that has been serving individuals and businesses in Florida for over 40 years. We offer a wide range of insurance products, including auto, home, and business insurance, as well as life insurance and recreational vehicle insurance. Our experienced agents work with clients to find the right coverage solutions for their unique needs. With a commitment to excellent service and customer satisfaction, we're dedicated to helping you protect what matters most.
The agency's professionalism, promptness, and ability to meet their clients' insurance needs are highly praised.
One reviewer had a negative experience with an agent, citing unprofessional behavior.
4.8
Based on 45 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Fuqua Insurance Agency is a locally-owned insurance agency based in Tallahassee, FL, providing a wide range of insurance services, including auto, home, commercial, and life insurance. With 45 years of service, the agency prides itself on providing affordable rates and exceptional customer service. From bundling policies to finding the best coverage plans, Fuqua Insurance Agency is committed to serving the community with a personalized approach. Whether you're a young adult, single or family, Fuqua Insurance Agency is dedicated to finding you the right policy for your needs and budget.
The reviewers have nothing but praise for the Fuqua Insurance Agency, citing excellent customer service, competitive quotes, and seamless transitions.
4.8
Based on 42 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Chancy Insurance is a full-service independent insurance agency serving Florida and Georgia for over 20 years. We offer a wide range of insurance products for both personal and commercial lines, including home, auto, life, and business insurance. Our experienced team provides exceptional customer service and personalized attention to ensure our clients receive the best coverage for their unique needs.
The majority of reviewers praised the company's excellent customer service, prompt service, and coverage.
One reviewer criticized the owner's attitude and lack of responsiveness.
4.7
Based on 19 reviews
Profile Website Phone
State Farm Insurance Agent Tiffany Surles is a trusted insurance provider in Florida, offering personalized insurance services to individuals, families, and businesses. With over 15 years of experience, the agency provides a range of insurance products, including auto, homeowners, renters, business, life, health, and recreational vehicles insurance. The team is dedicated to providing expert guidance and personalized service to ensure clients receive the best possible coverage for their unique needs.
Overall, customers have praised State Farm for its excellent customer service, knowledgeable agents, and affordable rates.
Some customers have expressed frustration with the company's communication and transparency, particularly in regards to policy changes.
4.5
Based on 16 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Dick Franklin State Farm Insurance is a reputable insurance agency based in Tallahassee, Florida, offering a wide range of insurance products, including auto, homeowners, condo, renters, business, life, health, pet, and recreational vehicles insurance. With years of experience and a passion for helping others, the agency is dedicated to providing personalized insurance solutions that cater to the unique needs of its clients.
State Farm agents provide exceptional customer service, are knowledgeable, and helpful in saving customers money on their insurance policies.
Some customers experience unexpected rate increases, poor communication, and inconsistent information from agents.
4.1
Based on 43 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Jerrell Lowery Ins Agcy Inc is a trusted insurance agency offering a wide range of insurance products, including auto, homeowners, condo, renters, business, life, health, pet, and more. Our experienced team provides personalized quotes, file claims, and offer banking services. With a strong presence in Tallahassee, Florida, we are committed to helping our customers protect their assets and achieve their long-term financial goals. By partnering with State Farm Insurance, we offer a comprehensive range of insurance solutions to suit the unique needs of our clients. From auto insurance to business insurance, we have the expertise and resources to provide the best possible coverage for our customers.
Many customers have praised the company's excellent customer service and reasonable prices.
Some customers have reported issues with the company's services, including lack of follow-through on roadside assistance and mistakes with billing and paperwork.
4.1
Based on 15 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Personal Insurance Federation of Florida (PIFF) is a leading advocate for insurance consumers in Florida. With a focus on homeowners, flood, and auto insurance, PIFF works to ensure that consumers have access to affordable, reliable insurance coverage. PIFF is dedicated to promoting a healthy insurance marketplace, reducing fraud and abuse, and educating consumers about their rights and responsibilities. Through advocacy, education, and community outreach, PIFF strives to protect the interests of Florida insurance consumers.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Legacy Insurance Solutions is a full-service insurance agency offering personal and commercial coverage options in Florida and nationwide. With offices in Tallahassee and Palm Beach, we provide personalized service, expert advice, and tailored solutions to individuals and businesses. Our insurance services include personal auto, home, life, and health plans, as well as commercial property, casualty, and group benefit packages.
Wade and the insurance agency received high praise for their expertise and trustworthiness.
The company was accused of scams, poor customer service, and ignoring customer requests.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
As a State Farm Insurance Agent, I have been helping individuals and families in Tallahassee, FL protect what matters most to them for over 33 years. With a wide range of insurance products including auto, homeowners, condo, renters, business, life, health, and pet insurance, I provide personalized options and guidance to ensure my clients' insurance needs are met. With my expertise and credentials, including the Chartered Financial (ChFC), Chartered Life Underwriter (CLU), and Chartered Advisor for Senior Living (CASL), I am dedicated to providing exceptional service and helping my clients navigate the complex world of insurance. My agency offers 24-hour after-hour service, and I am committed to being a trusted and knowledgeable advisor for my clients.
The staff at Dave Williams State Farm office are highly praised for their exceptional customer service, responsiveness, and knowledge.
One reviewer expresses frustration with State Farm corporate, citing slow response times and issues with their system.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Marks Insurance Agency is a full-service independent insurance agency dedicated to providing personalized insurance services to individuals and businesses. With a rich history dating back to 1930, we have established ourselves as a trusted advocate for our clients, offering quality insurance and risk management options combined with outstanding service and attention to detail. We are committed to finding solutions for insurance services that are right for you, your family, and your business.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
At Thielen Plus Insurance & Financial Services, we offer boutique insurance planning designed to delight you with an unparalleled service experience! Our Agency Principal, Adam Thielen, brings 40 years of experience helping families and businesses choose the right protection for the people and things they value most. We provide a personalized approach to insurance planning, serving the entire state of Florida from our location in Tallahassee. Our services include life and health insurance, auto and home insurance, business insurance, retirement planning, and more.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
The Insurance Center of Tallahassee, Florida, is an Independent Agency that specializes in insurance policies for Cars, Trucks, Boats, Motorcycles, and Recreational Vehicles (RVs). We provide coverage throughout the entire state of Florida, offering competitive rates and high-quality, responsive, and professional customer service. Our team is dedicated to helping individuals and families find the right insurance coverage for their needs.
The reviewers praise the agency for its excellent service, expertise, and personalized approach, with many expressing loyalty and trust.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Andrew Jackson Insurance of Tallahassee, Florida, is a reputable insurance broker that provides convenient insurance services, connecting you with top providers in the industry. We offer policies for businesses, associations, and nonprofits, as well as individuals. Our experienced team offers direct, personal service, ensuring your complete satisfaction. With over 60 years of combined experience, we'll find the perfect policy for you. Reach out to us today to ask for a free quote and let us take care of all your insurance needs.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Florida School Boards Insurance Trust (FSBIT) is a dedicated organization serving education through its member school districts. It provides risk management and loss prevention services, focusing on the qualifications and experience of its staff and board of directors. FSBIT offers competitive pricing, exceptional service, and products that are meaningful, cost-effective, and tailored to meet district needs. The organization also offers emergency advantage, cyber coverage, and drone services to its members.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Providing custom solutions for nearly all your insurance needs, Demont Insurance was founded in 1964 to bring quality and value to our clients. We believe in order to help protect the best things in life, you must work with a top insurance agent that listens to you. That's why our Florida insurance agency is dedicated to equipping our clients with the tools and resources needed to dream it, do it, and defend it with Demont.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Cairo (30.7 mi) Thomasville (32.8 mi) Bainbridge (36.6 mi) Chattahoochee (38.1 mi) Perry (47.3 mi)